Expressing Yourself Through Writing
Many people believed that STROL was a great system that
allowed teachers to understand the true meaning of diversity and allowed
students to express themselves in their own language. STROL was also used to
allow students to write in their own discourses without the fear of rejection
or teachers enforcing a standard way of writing. Many people came to realize
that everyone is different and many people talk and write differently then Proper English, but that doesn’t mean you have to make them feel like
their doing something wrong. In the
article Students Rights to Their Own Language stated, “We need to ask ourselves whether our rejection of students who do not
adopt the dialect most familiar to us is based on any real merit in our dialect
or whether we are actually rejecting the students themselves, rejecting them
because of their racial, social, and cultural origins”. Rejecting people
because they have different cultural backgrounds is not the right way to go
about it. I think its very interesting learning about different cultures
because it allows you to get a sense of who someone else is and how they do
things that are different from the way you do things.
Writing
is used as a form of expression and some people feel the most comfortable when
writing in their own discourse/language. Sometimes it’s hard writing when you
feel like it’s not your true self because your teacher told you to write this
way. Many people want to feel free writing the way they want to and not the way
someone else wants to.
accentadventure.com |
At
times I have a hard time expressing my true self because the way I talk is
different from the way I write. Growing up I was taught to write a certain way
and that people should not use slang as a form of writing. If I write “Luv u 4
ever” in my essay I will feel like I’m writing in a wrong way. I was always
taught to articulate my words properly in a way anyone can understand me.
Jeff
Zorn argues that STROL is not a great system for students. He believes STROL
holds students back from officially getting them the standard academics they
need. I think he feels that if students want to get far in life they need to
establish proper English so they will be able to communicate with a variety of
people. Zorn states, “SRTOL plants the seeds of Pyrrhic victory in students; it tells
them they win when they continue to speak and write their vernacular despite
all appearances (low grades, low test scores, bad interviews, bad job performance
ratings, etc.) to the contrary. This was my mentors’ exact insight: the
disadvantaged cannot afford Pyrrhic victories”. He feels that students are not
achieving using STROL because they are not gaining any important skills that
will help strengthen their writing. Many people may have different views on
STROL but it still gives students the right to write in a way they feel
secured.
No comments:
Post a Comment